Crazy Real Estate Stories

This Fort Worth castle built for a Texas Rangers co-owner is back on the auction block

The house at 9553 Bella Terra Drive, in Fort Worth's gated Montserrat community, is back at auction with Concierge Auctions. Bidding started November 4, 2026 and closes November 20, 2026. The details below come from Kenzie Johnson's Fort Worth Magazine article, published November 6, 2026.

By Michael O'Neal, Broker and REALTOR®, Keller Williams Realty Northeast
Published November 14, 2026

What is back at auction

I am keeping this to what Fort Worth Magazine reported. The address is 9553 Bella Terra Drive, in Fort Worth's gated Montserrat community. J. Lambert Custom Homes built the house in 2006 for Bob Simpson, a former co-owner of the Texas Rangers. Simpson sold it in 2021 to its current owner. The design is Tuscany-inspired and European chateau-style, with a stone facade and ornate interior detailing.

How the price has moved

The price path is what I want Houston sellers to see. The house was first listed in November 2025 at $11.75 million, and it did not find an early buyer. In December 2025 it went to Concierge Auctions, where it reportedly sold for $6.72 million. The reported sale did not close.

It came back on the market in March 2026, priced at $7.5 million. Concierge Auctions has it again. Bidding started November 4, 2026 and closes November 20, 2026, with a starting range around $2 million to $4 million.

What the house includes

The lot is about 2 acres. Living space is nearly 20,000 square feet, with seven bedroom suites and more than a dozen baths.

For the amenities, I am staying with what the article cites from the Realtor.com listing: a temperature-controlled wine gallery, a movie theater, a gym, and an elevator. The article also cites that listing for a separate 4,734-square-foot guest residence, a private pond, a sports court, indoor and outdoor pools, and several terraces.

What I would tell a Houston buyer or seller

My take is for people buying and selling around Houston, not a value on this Fort Worth house. I work with buyers and sellers in Houston, Kingwood and around Lake Houston. I would not carry these Fort Worth prices over to a house in those neighborhoods.

A price that falls from an $11.75 million ask to a $2 million to $4 million auction starting range shows how overpricing a very custom, one-of-a-kind house can backfire. A winning bid that fails to close puts a home back at square one. Pricing to the market, and vetting a buyer's ability to close, matter at every price point, including in Kingwood and around Lake Houston.

If you want me to walk through pricing, or through whether a buyer can close, call or text me at 832-797-3780. Start on my sell page, or read my Kingwood guide.

Sources: Fort Worth Magazine, “Bob Simpson's Former Montserrat Mansion Is on the Market,” by Kenzie Johnson, Nov. 6, 2026. Listing details and the price can change. This property is not listed by The Michael O'Neal Group.

Buying or selling in Kingwood, around Lake Houston, or anywhere in Greater Houston? Call me.

832-797-3780 Text Michael

Send Me a Message

Related

Keep going

Related guides and tools

Ask about this article

The O’Neal Insider · Free weekly

Get the Houston Neighborhood Insider.

Local events, neighborhood updates, and real estate insights for the areas you care about. Read the latest edition.

Which areas and topics? Pick any.Areas
Also want text alerts? (optional)